Menu
My Bag

Your bag is currently empty.

Menu

Mr. Bates vs the Post Office,

The Alan Bates vs British Post Office story - Absent Justice

 

 

Secret email about the Post Office Scandal. Shh!   Prefer to view online? Click here...
 
 

Hello!

After covering the story on Times Radio on Thursday evening, I helped provide some information for a piece by Ali Mitib in the Times today about the likelihood of prosecutions of those responsible for the Post Office scandal. The bad news is that any prosecutions won't start until 2027 and possibly not before 2028. 

You can read the full Times article here. Hopefully it also made the print edition. I do like reading the Saturday Times "in the flesh" when I get the chance. Today I have a good excuse to go and buy it!

More PO IT woe

To the surprise of no-one, the Post Office has binned its Horizon IT replacement, known as The Project Formerly Known As NBIT. The PO has wasted tens of millions of pounds on this folly and it should hang like a millstone around outgoing CEO Nick Read's neck. 

Read had lots of jobs, but replacing Horizon was a very important one. As CEO, NBIT was his decision and his unfolding disaster to own and monitor. How and why he decided to do it in-house without properly scoping the competence of his execs to even hire the right people, let alone design and manage a project of this importance is beyond me. Read completely and utterly failed, costing his organisation and the goverment a fortune, none of which he will ever be held accountable for.

More in the Daily Mail, here.

Issy Hogg

Thanks to everyone who got in touch re the sad passing of Issy Hogg. I have added comments to my piece from Lord Arbuthnot and Amanda Butler (née Glover). Vic, Issy's partner, kindly allowed me to use a newer photo of Issy at the bottom of the article. He also asked that anyone wishing to come to the funeral on 18 Dec get in touch with him first as they are almost at capacity at Basingstoke Crematorium. Vic's email address is vic.hogg@icloud.com.

Thanks

I am deeply grateful to the new subscribers who have joined this mailing list recently, and profound thanks to those who have signed up to my (free) gender newsletter. I've done no work on it or accompanying website at all so I need to turn my attention to that now.

Feel free to have a look around and sign up if you're interested in hearing about the gender wars. Warning: the website is still very much a work in progress, so please don't expect much for the time being.

Back a week on Monday with news of the first day of closing submission from the Post Office Horizon IT Inquiry.

Have a great weekend.

Nick

Chris Head: an open letter to Gareth Thomas, Post Office minister

 Chris Head became Britain’s youngest ever Subpostmaster at the age of 18. In 2006 he was given the keys to the West Bolden branch near Sunderland. According to an interview he gave to The Sun newspaper, Chris had small discrepancies from the start of his tenure. In 2014, Chris says the Post Office’s Horizon IT system at his branch “went out of control“. One week Chris had a £40,000 shortfall. Within a few weeks it had more than doubled to £88,000. Chris was suspended in 2015 and the Post Office pursued him through the civil courts for the cash they...

 

Thanks

Nick Wallis

----------------

The body set up to advise the government on matters relating to compensating Subpostmasters has called for the quashing of all convictions brought using data from a predecessor to the Horizon IT system. Professor Chris Hodes, chair of the Horizon Compensation Advisory Board (HCAB), has written to the Lord Chancellor about the Capture system, a piece of accounting software sold by the Post Office to its Subpostmasters between 1992 and 1999. “Evidence” from the Capture system was sometimes used to prosecute Subpostmasters who had accounting discrepancies in their branches. A recent report by the investigations agency Kroll concluded that “there...

 

Lisa Busch KC

 Lisa Busch KC, one of the most significant unsung heroes in the Post Office scandal, has died after a short illness. Busch represented former Subpostmasters Seema Misra, Janet Skinner and Tracey Felstead at the Court of Appeal Hamilton hearings in 2021 after the barrister Paul Marshall and his junior Flora Page were forced to stand down. It was Busch’s advocacy, using arguments grounded in Marshall and Page’s work, which persuaded the Court of Appeal that the Post Office perpetrated a Category 2 abuse of process. I watched Ms Busch make her arguments in court during the Hamilton hearings. She was...

If that doesn't work, copy and paste the following link in your browser:

https://www.postofficescandal.uk/post/lisa-busch-kc/

Thanks

Nick Wallis

 

Hollinrake’s legacy: Postmasters dying without full redress

 The day began with a tolling of the metaphorical bell. Before the former Post Office minister Kevin Hollinrake gave evidence, the chair of the Post Office Inquiry, Sir Wyn Williams, told us that another former Subpostmaster has died, again without receiving full and final compensation. Her name was Carol Riddell. She was the Subpostmaster at East Bolden, near Sunderland, between 1992 and 2000. Sir Wyn told the Inquiry: “During her time as sub-postmistress, Mrs Riddell had to contend with a very serious armed robbery at her post office, during the course of which she was blinded by having acid thrown...

If that doesn't work, copy and paste the following link in your browser:

https://www.postofficescandal.uk/post/hollinrakes-legacy-postmasters-dying-without-full-redress/

Thanks

Nick Wallis

 

Chisholm: helping Paula Vennells fail upwards

 Sir Alex Chisholm KCB was one of the most powerful government civil servants during a crucial phase of the Post Office scandal, and to nerds like me, his evidence was always going to be of some interest. Chisholm made it quite clear (watch it here) he was crawling all over the Post Office’s disastrous defence to the Bates v Post Office group litigation, but that every duff decision was its to make alone. “I was very clear in my advice to the Secretary of State”, Chisholm told the Inquiry, “that the department need to be a neutral party in relation to...

Absent Justice Ebook

Read Alan’s new book
‘Absent Justice’

I am excited to share the announcement of my first book, *Absent Justice*, which marks the beginning of a thoughtful trilogy dedicated to exposing and addressing the corrupt practices that have gradually influenced the Australian way of life. This book is available for Order Now—It's Free, making it accessible to a wide audience who may benefit from its insights.

 *Absent Justice* is the result of extensive and comprehensive research, which includes a thorough examination of existing literature, interviews with key stakeholders, and meticulous evidence collection. The narrative presents a compelling exploration of critical issues related to justice and equity within Australia's arbitration and mediation systems. By delving into real-world examples and case studies, the book aims to shed light on the systemic challenges that many individuals face when seeking fair treatment and resolution.

I invite readers to engage with this work and reflect on the importance of the research and evidence that underpin its findings. If you value the insights presented and are inclined to support the pursuit of transparency, I would greatly appreciate your consideration of a donation to Transparency International Australia. Your contribution can significantly enhance efforts to promote integrity and accountability within our society, ultimately benefiting all Australians.

Quote Icon

“A number of people seem to be experiencing some or all of the problems which you have outlined to me. …

“I trust that your meeting tomorrow with Senators Alston and Boswell is a profitable one.”

Hon David Hawker MP

“…your persistence to bring about improvements to Telecom’s country services. I regret that it was at such a high personal cost.”

Hon David Hawker

“…the very large number of persons that had been forced into an arbitration process and have been obliged to settle as a result of the sheer weight that Telstra has brought to bear on them as a consequence where they have faced financial ruin if they did not settle…”

Senator Carr

“Only I know from personal experience that your story is true, otherwise I would find it difficult to believe. I was amazed and impressed with the thorough, detailed work you have done in your efforts to find justice”

Sister Burke

“I am writing in reference to your article in last Friday’s Herald-Sun (2nd April 1993) about phone difficulties experienced by businesses.

I wish to confirm that I have had problems trying to contact Cape Bridgewater Holiday Camp over the past 2 years.

I also experienced problems while trying to organise our family camp for September this year. On numerous occasions I have rung from both this business number 053 424 675 and also my home number and received no response – a dead line.

I rang around the end of February (1993) and twice was subjected to a piercing noise similar to a fax. I reported this incident to Telstra who got the same noise when testing.”

Cathy Lindsey

“Only I know from personal experience that your story is true, otherwise I would find it difficult to believe. I was amazed and impressed with the thorough, detailed work you have done in your efforts to find justice”

Sister Burke

Were you denied justice in arbitration?

Would you like your story told on absentjustice.com?
 Contact Us